CAL.
The CAL Journal

Leadership

Before the difficult conversation

How to give feedback that stays focused on the work: research, a preparation worksheet and a conversation you can adapt.

CAL Editorial · 7 min read

The conversation you postpone is still shaping the team

A deadline slips for the second time. A colleague interrupts someone in a meeting. A capable team member keeps avoiding a decision. You know a conversation is needed, but you are waiting for the right moment or the right words. Meanwhile, the rest of the team is working around the problem.

The answer is not simply to become more direct. Feedback can help, but it can also distract people from the work they need to improve. A useful leadership conversation makes the concern specific, leaves room for information you do not have and ends with an action both people understand. This article offers a preparation process you can use for an ordinary performance conversation, not a substitute for formal HR procedures.

What the evidence says about feedback

In their 1996 meta-analysis, Avraham Kluger and Angelo DeNisi examined 607 effect sizes covering 23,663 observations. Feedback improved performance on average, yet more than one-third of the feedback interventions decreased performance. Their analysis suggested that effectiveness declined as attention moved towards the self and away from the task. [1]

That does not mean one-third of your conversations will go badly. The review pooled different tasks and interventions; it does not predict an individual outcome. It does challenge the idea that giving feedback is automatically helpful. A practical implication is to talk about a behaviour someone can change, rather than turning the issue into a judgement of their character.

Amy Edmondson’s 1999 field study of 51 teams in one manufacturing company found that team psychological safety was associated with learning behaviour. Psychological safety meant a shared belief that the team was safe for interpersonal risk-taking. This was an observational study in a particular setting, not proof that a particular script causes better performance. [2]

The coaching recommendation here is to combine clarity with curiosity: state the concern without humiliating the person, and make it possible for them to question an assumption or explain an obstacle. Being open to their explanation does not mean giving up your standards.

Prepare four lines before you speak

First, write the observation. What happened, when, and what had been agreed? Use an event another person could recognise: “The report was due on Tuesday and arrived on Thursday.” Avoid “You never take deadlines seriously”, which combines exaggeration with an assumption about motivation.

Second, write the impact. What became harder because of the event? “The reviewers had one day rather than three, and two checks were postponed.” Keep this proportionate. Do not add consequences you cannot support just to make the concern sound important.

Third, write your question. Choose something you genuinely do not know: “What got in the way of delivering it on Tuesday?” Fourth, write the next standard you need: “For the next report, I need either delivery by Tuesday or an early warning that lets us adjust.” These four lines are preparation, not a speech to recite.

An opening you can adapt

Illustrative example, not a client account: “I want to discuss the last report. We agreed Tuesday, and it arrived Thursday. That shortened the review window and left two checks unfinished. I may be missing part of the picture. What happened?”

After asking, stop speaking. If the answer is “Another team gave me the figures late”, explore the dependency before assigning blame. Ask when the delay became visible, who could have helped and what escalation would look like next time. You may discover a coordination problem rather than a lack of effort.

If the person disputes your account, compare the evidence calmly. If you contributed to the problem through unclear priorities or a late change, say so. Owning your part makes the conversation more accurate; it does not cancel the other person’s responsibility.

End with an observable agreement

“Communicate better” is not a useful agreement. “Send a status update on Monday afternoon, and flag any missing inputs by noon” tells both people what to look for. Agree the action, the owner and the check-in date. Ask the other person to describe the plan in their own words so misunderstandings surface now.

Your follow-up should review what actually changed. Did the update arrive? Was the obstacle raised earlier? If not, revisit the barrier and whether the person had the authority, time and support to carry out the agreement. Do not use a friendly tone to hide a serious concern; be explicit if a formal process is required.

A ten-minute exercise for this week

Choose one conversation you have been postponing. Spend two minutes writing the facts without adjectives, two minutes identifying the work impact and two minutes listing what you might not know. Use the remaining four minutes to draft your opening and one realistic next action.

Before the meeting, check whether you would say the same words if your own manager were present. After it, record the agreement and the follow-up date. Judge the conversation by whether it created shared understanding and a clearer next step, not whether it felt perfectly comfortable.

For allegations involving harassment, discrimination, safeguarding or serious misconduct, use the appropriate reporting and HR processes rather than trying to resolve everything through an informal feedback conversation.

Sources

  1. [1]Kluger & DeNisi (1996). The effects of feedback interventions on performance. Psychological Bulletin, 119(2), 254–284.
  2. [2]Edmondson (1999). Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383.